Articles

How Many Upper Endoscopies to Be Competent? The Evidence

How many upper endoscopies to be competent depends on the skill measured, and no Egyptian source reviewed here sets a count. A US benchmark study put overall competence at about 250 procedures, duodenal intubation at 100 to 150, and societies set minimums from 130 to 1,000, so trainees in Egypt should read these against their own programme.

Gastroscope beside a monitor: how many upper endoscopies to be competent

Most evidence points to 200 to 250 supervised upper endoscopies, but a bare count is a weak yardstick. A US benchmark study of fellows found overall competence at an average of about 250 procedures (Miller et al., 2019).

How many upper endoscopies to be competent, skill by skill

In that study of 96 fellows, competence meant an average ACE-E score of 3.5 plus independent D2 intubation at least 95% of the time within 4.75 minutes. Fellows met the D2 criteria at around 100 to 150 procedures, but most other thresholds took 200 to 250, and recognition of pathologic states took 300 (Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2019; full text).

A UK national analysis of 243,555 upper GI endoscopies found trainees reached 95% unassisted D2 completion at 187 procedures, and over 90% had reached it after 200 (Gut, 2017). That makes 200 procedures a reasonable floor for intubation alone.

Society minimums side by side

Published minimums run from 130 to 1,000 depending on the body (2023 systematic review).

Body (year) Upper endoscopy minimum
ASGE, US (2017) 130, plus 95% pylorus intubation
CAG, Canada (2008) 150 (100 unassisted)
Conjoint Committee, Australia (2015) 200 supervised
New Zealand (2022) 200 supervised
JAG, UK (2022) 250 (190 unassisted)
Switzerland (2013) 400 supervised
KSGE, Korea (2017) 1,000

The older ASGE figure of 130 was a minimum before assessment, and a commentary on the US data suggests competence may take nearly double that (Kolb and Wagh). The 2023 review found D2 intubation rate the only consistent quality indicator across most guidelines (review), so a logbook total is a floor, not proof. The validated ACE tool was completed after every 50 procedures in its validation study (source).

Emergency bleeding and advanced procedures

A single-centre study of 787 bleeding cases suggested at least 20 emergency EGDs with recent haemorrhage before independent work, though its authors note the thresholds come from one centre (2024 study). Advanced procedures run higher: about 225 cases for core EUS and 250 for ERCP (trainee study).

What this means for a trainee in Egypt

No Egyptian source reviewed here sets an upper-endoscopy count, so these are international benchmarks. Confirm your own programme's logbook requirement and use these numbers to read it, not replace it.

The WGO Cairo Training Center at the Theodor Bilharz Research Institute describes a three-level pathway (diagnostic, therapeutic, advanced) in a unit it says handles about 140 to 150 procedures a week. Fees for a short hands-on course are covered in what doctors pay for an upper GI endoscopy course in Egypt.

What a short course covers and what is not included

A short hands-on course adds technique, not counts: Dextrology's Upper GI Endoscopy course runs 19 to 21 November 2026 at Kasr Al Ainy, Cairo, with Prof. Dr. Mahmoud Wahba and one-to-one supervision on a real patient. It does not replace a logbook and grants no clinical privileges.

The evidence above points to the right way to use one: keep logging supervised procedures, and have each block of about 50 scored with a validated tool, as the ACE validation study did, so technique practice feeds a measured record instead of a bare total.

Next step

By Dr. Omar Yasser, Licensed Physician. To compare formats and dates, Explore Dextrology courses. Before you rely on any count in this article, ask your programme director how logbook entries are signed off, whether procedures are scored with a structured tool, and which skills, such as D2 intubation, are assessed separately. Whatever you choose, your programme's logbook and assessments remain the record of competence.

Explore Dextrology courses

Frequently asked questions

How many EGDs do you need before performing independently?

There is no universal number. Society minimums before or for assessment range from 130 to 1,000, and JAG in the UK lists 250 (190 unassisted). A US benchmark study put overall competence at about 250, and a single-centre bleeding study suggested at least 20 emergency EGDs with recent haemorrhage. Confirm your own programme's logbook requirement.

Is 200 procedures enough to be competent in gastroscopy?

Often for intubation, less reliably for everything. In UK data, over 90% of trainees had reached 95% unassisted D2 completion after 200 procedures. In the US benchmark study, overall competence averaged about 250 and recognition of pathologic states about 300. So 200 is a reasonable floor for reaching the duodenum, not a finish line.

How is competence in upper endoscopy assessed?

Through measured performance, not just a count. Studies use independent D2 intubation at least 95% of the time, intubation time (4.75 minutes or less in one US study) and a validated tool such as ACE, scored after each block of 50 procedures. Your own programme decides what counts locally.

Can a short course replace logbook procedures?

No. A short course supports technique, but the evidence on competence is built on supervised procedures counted and assessed over time. Dextrology's three-day Upper GI Endoscopy course (19 to 21 November 2026, Kasr Al Ainy) gives one-to-one supervision on a real patient, but it does not replace a logbook or grant clinical privileges.

References

  1. Overall competence benchmarks for gastroenterology fellows (Miller et al.) and commentary (Kolb and Wagh)
  2. Competency in esophagogastroduodenoscopy: a validated tool for assessment and generalizable benchmarks for gastroenterology fellows
  3. UK national analysis of trainee upper GI endoscopy learning curves
  4. Systematic review of GI endoscopy training guidelines
  5. Learning curve in emergency endoscopy for upper GI bleeding
  6. Learning curves of ASGE-recognised advanced endoscopy trainees (ERCP and EUS)
  7. Validated ACE tool for upper endoscopy assessment

Written for education. It does not replace local guidelines, senior advice or supervised training.